Imperiia: a spatial history of the Russian EmpireMain MenuAboutProjectsDashboardsData CatalogMapStoriesGalleriesGamesWho said history was boring?Teach Our ContentCiting the ProjectKelly O'Neilldc20b45f1d74122ba0d654d19961d826c5a557f5The Imperiia Project // Davis Center for Russian and Eurasian Studies, Harvard University
Creating data: critical reading
12018-02-08T06:07:10-05:00Kelly O'Neilldc20b45f1d74122ba0d654d19961d826c5a557f591plain2018-02-08T11:48:05-05:00Kelly O'Neilldc20b45f1d74122ba0d654d19961d826c5a557f5What does it mean to read a source critically? It means reading with the desire to understand why the source was written, when it was written, who wrote it, for whom, to what end, and in what context. It means taking as little as possible for granted about the source, but never losing faith that in the end it will teach you something about the past.
This page is referenced by:
12018-02-07T03:13:23-05:00Converting Documents to Data1plain2019-06-27T01:50:24-04:00Scholars in some fields have the pleasure of downloading ready-made (though never perfect) data to use in their analyses. Those of us attempting to map the past are rarely so fortunate. Instead, it falls to us to translate the historical record into the lingua franca of the digital age. In some cases this process can be automated; in others it must be done by hand.
Either way, the task is daunting. After all, imperial regimes generated an astonishing amount of paper. The process of moving from document to data involves some combination of the following steps (which are often repeated and do not necessarily happen in neat order):
critical study of the source
articulation of the kinds of information it contains
assessment of the scalability of the information
identification of the ways in which the information from this source relates to the information contained in other sources
reorganization of the source information as data
documentation of the decisions that enable the conversion from source to spreadsheet
This process applies to the full range of historical sources: archival documents, historical maps, paintings, narrative texts, statistical tables, you name it. The point is not to simplify or reduce the complexity of historical source, but rather to identify its constituent parts and innovate ways to allow sources from a variety of genres to "speak" to one another.